The bun in this song is driving me crazy that I'm going to think about it here with you out loud:
When she talks to HIM saying: Я твой голос и ты НЕМОЙ стал
As far as I know in grammar: with the case of НЕМОЙ, there must be an OBJECT "Я твой голос и ты НЕМОЙ стал ЧЕМ-Н"And it will be translated as: "I'm your voice and you are a mute who became ........". But here there is no OBJECT.
This can mean: I'm your voice and you became mute. but in this case it must be немЫМ. But it is not.
My last choice would be, that she is saying: I'm your voice and you became A MUTE WOMAN. but it sounds very weird to me.
I'm I thinking right or what?
Голос
Voice
Thanks! ❤ | ||
thanked 7 times |
Thanks Details:
User | Time ago |
---|---|
someone | 2 years 10 months |
AquaticFlint | 4 years 1 month |
Sr. Sermás | 7 years 2 months |
Ww Ww | 7 years 6 months |
Eagles Hunter | 7 years 6 months |
The song is based on the pun
не мой - not mine; немой - numb
1. | Сансара (Sansara) |
2. | Выпускной (Медлячок) |
3. | Неболей (Neboley) |
1. | на совесть |
Okay, Amr, let's start step by step.
1. .... ты не мой стал. Я твой голос и ты немой стал.
First of all, the word order isn't direct here (you know it's flexible in Russian) A translator gives you a wrong translation. The phrase goes Ты стал не мой/немой
So there's no object needed. Ты стал каким? =Не моим/Немым But in this case the pun is lost. You can say that's not good Russian. No, it's not, I agree. But translators don't discuss what they have to translate. They just translate what they have to. Btw, in colloquial Russian you can say (meeting someone after a long no see) Ты стал такой взрослый/большой/красивый instead of взрослым/ большим/красивым.
The difference between не мой/немой can only be seen, not heard
I'll change my translation into not mine- numb At least there's some semblance in sounds. :)
So, we can say that: this structure/ these cases of "не мой/немой" is grammatically WRONG. However, it is still acceptable (maybe it is considered either very colloquial or illiterate structure). Did I get it right now?
Я сам своим глазам не верю!!
Посмотрите пожалуйста Надя на что написано в этой статии.
http://mnogo-smysla.ru/smysl-pesen/smysl-pesni-basta-polina-gagarina-golos/
С моей "космической" точкой зрения она совпадает.
УРА УРА УРААААА
Спасибо Надя
quoted from http://text-lyrics.ru/b1/basta/3842-basta-golos-ft-polina-gagarina-perev...