Быть собой
Thanks! ❤ | ||
thanked 4 times |
Thanks Details:
User | Time ago |
---|---|
Radu Robert | 5 years 1 month |
Igeethecat | 5 years 1 month |
BlackSea4ever | 5 years 1 month |
rakhilalala | 5 years 1 month |
1. | Throw It Away |
2. | Blue Monk |
3. | The Music Is the Magic |
1. | As cold as stone |
- Давайте ещё посоветуемся по поводу трактовки этих двух строчек с англо-саксами дополнительно? ;) Вы могли бы обратиться к носителям языка с детства с просьбой развёрнутого анализа смысла их?
Песня не англо-саксаулськая, потому попросила совета у кореного американца ;)
- Всё-таки мне представляется, что вторая строка не должна логически противоречить первой, поэтому:
All along the way there were things to do - Всё долгое время всё делалось (кем-то)
Always some other someone I could be --- Всегда другими, кем я могла бы быть
То есть: она выражает сожаление/досаду, что кто-то другой делал долго то, что могла бы делать она. Возможно не хуже, а лучше, или по-другому:
Многое узнать, другие пути избрать
И вдохновенную себя на сцене показать
?
[@phil Ambro] can you please help us to describe the first 2 lines,
On, well and the rest of the song too :)
Be careful what you are asking for...
Anyway, what can be unclear in the 1st two lines? My translation was pretty literal
All along the way there were things to do --> всю жизнь работала
Always some other someone I could be. --> всегда играла чьи-то другие образы
--
Дальше, все четко тоже. Разве не было такой Русской песни о актрисе?
Sorry, but I do not get your translation. You can google the meaning of the song and post some facts outside of your own interpretation.
And remember, you are not native, so be careful...
I need not be careful. I am confident in my translation. Got native snoring beside me.
Ah, I'm sorry, I didn't realize my comments were unwelcome. Sorry. Good night.
Here is what I read
https://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/20/arts/music/20chin.html
Yes, just like this one. So, M, looks like you're going for the role of agent provocateur...
Она была актрисою, и даже за кулисами
Играла роль, а зрителем был я.
В душе ее таинственной мирилась ложь и истина
Актрисы непростого ремесла.
Ему единственно верна хотела быть она.
И каждый день я шел за ней,
На зов обманчивых огней.
И с нею жизнь чужую проживал.
Я знал, что ей не быть со мной.
Она раба любви иной,
И жизнь ее – безумный карнавал.
И рампы свет заменит ей тепло любви моей.
Припев:
Красота актрисы так обманчива
И влечет напрасными надеждами
Ничего слова ее не значили
И в судьбе моей все по-прежнему.
Она была актрисою,
И даже за кулисами
Играла роль, а я хотел любви.
И каждый день, идя за ней на зов обманчивых огней,
Душа моя кричала: «Позови!»
Но рампы свет манил сильней,
Сильней любви моей.
Припев:
Красота актрисы так обманчива
И влечет напрасными надеждами
Ничего слова ее не значили
И в судьбе моей все по-прежнему.
Красота актрисы так обманчива
И влечет напрасными надеждами
Ничего слова ее не значили
И в судьбе моей все по-прежнему.
И в судьбе моей все по-прежнему.
И в судьбе моей все по-прежнему.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sP4L8DJHcBg
IMHO, abbey's song is better, more bitter, more realistic
Pierre, as a performer, she needs inspiration, literally, a spirit flown in like the Russian word дух to get into a character, to bring in a realistic performance onto a stage
Дух? Может вдохновение?
Yep. Дух вдохновения! Can't I be whimsical and fanciful....lol
А по мне, то - душа
Yes! I started with it!
Lol, don't over analyze. What can it be?
Is she a ghost? Maybe now, but not at the time when song was written.
Is it spirit that, like you said, to be n high spirit - doesn't fit
Is it spirit as an inspiration - sure, she wants to be inspired and bring the essence, the truth, the realism into her performance
Spirit has many different meanings, the ones that apply best here are:
* the nonphysical part of a person which is the seat of emotions and character; the soul
* the immaterial intelligent or sentient part of a person
* the activating or essential principle influencing a person
* temper or disposition of mind or outlook especially when vigorous or animated (in high spirits)
* an inclination, impulse, or tendency of a specified kind (mood)
* the feeling, quality, or disposition characterizing something (undertaken in a spirit of fun)
I took these straight from the dictionary as I don't think I can paraphrase them well. It's a very nuanced word.
I’d wait for a native opinion
D, once again you don’t have to be rude
I wasn't rude, although, to avoid drama, I deleted my comment. I honestly haven't experienced a single occasion where what I said was untrue.
Depends on a native
In the lyrics it's written as "for the" instead of "for to," in this case "for the" means "so that..." or "in order to..."
"For to do something" can be said in English but it's very archaic, so it would only appear in old things like Shakespeare. In modern usage, it would be redundant. If we said "I go to school (for) to learn" it means the same as "I go to school to learn."
Sarah, in the original lyrics, it wasn't stage but play. Do you mean as it is sung, it should be "stage show" without TO in between?
The correct lyrics are what is written in the lyrics above, "fly a spirit for the stage to show," it's pronounced more like "fly a spirit for the stage t'show," which is a common way of transitioning from "to" to the next word. The other interpretations don't really make sense in English.
As for what she means by this, I don't know. "Fly the spirit" isn't something I've heard before, so it's definitely figurative. But based on the context of the song, I'm guessing she's talking about her inner spirit, energy, being, etc. and that she had to show a certain version of herself (or spirit) on stage, but that wasn't really who she is. (Which is why she says "Always some other someone I could be").
It seems to make sense since the song is about becoming herself, and famous singers, etc. often struggle with who they are as a person versus their stage persona and how they are seen a performer, so that's just my guess.
ahh off topic .. it says video unavailable maybe add this one ? https://youtu.be/eHZpA55AFcM
Off topic 2 .. i will so do this in Romanian , as how i see it in my own interpretation not in literal .. the song kinda request it to be done that way .. ' tis full of in behind meanings ..
That being said keep it cool guys .. and all the best on this nice weekend !!
Is it forbidden to comment ? Think not , as long as the comment is polite and all that i see no problem . Do you ? I commented sharing nice vibes and all that .. is it that a problem .. ? See ya around and goodl luck with understanding the song :)).. a thing that is kinda hard to do , if ya won t put soul, sometimes even research and pasion in what "you" (maybe not you personally idk .. just saying that there are some of these type around ) do , and just translate line by line without seeing their correlation ..
- Немножко подредактировал, "причесал"... :)
All along the way there were things to do
Always some {comma?} other someone I could be
===
As cryptic as it is, I personally understand it as :
По жизни, у меня был выбор
Всегда, и я могла бы быть другой
:)