roster 31
Thu, 02/02/2017 - 14:51
José Martí (El Libertador de Cuba) is the author of the poem (poems), not a performer.
| Thanks! ❤ thanked 207 times |
| You can thank submitter by pressing this button |
Thanks Details:
| User | Time ago |
|---|---|
| Κακομάζαλη | 2 years 5 months |
| sandring | 6 years 6 months |
Lobolyrix on 2017-02-02Guantanamera > Guantánamo Province
Guajira: Female (white) peasant in Cuba as well as the Cuban music style Guajira
The original verses are written by the Cuban national hero José Martí (1853 - 1895).
roster 31
Thu, 02/02/2017 - 14:51
José Martí (El Libertador de Cuba) is the author of the poem (poems), not a performer.
Aldefina
Thu, 02/02/2017 - 16:29
He is listed as an artist, not a performer: https://lyricstranslate.com/en/jos%C3%A9-mart%C3%AD-lyrics.html
That's the way how our software works, we cannot separate poets from singers - they are all listed in the same category - and I'm not sure whether that would be a good idea. I have submitted one poem of Andrzej Waligórski, as a poem. He wrote it just before his death knowing that those were his last days. I also posted a video with a song, but it was never intended to be a song (the same story with José Martí). The song was recorded few years after his death.
I think we should leave it as it is. I believe it's better this way.
Lobolyrix
Thu, 02/02/2017 - 17:20
Hello Rosa, for a moment I was irritated, me too, to find the well known 'Libertador de Cuba' listed as an 'artist' - never heard that he performed any songs... :). But Andrzej is right, we translate here songs as well as poems. And please note, you can find here even Miguel de Cervantes, William Shakespeare, Johann W. von Goethe and Friedrich Schiller, all them listed as 'artists...
Maybe that editors sometimes should draw a better distinction between 'artists' and 'performers', this could prevent confusions.
Aldefina
Thu, 02/02/2017 - 17:42
Exactly, Wolfgang, you're right. We may introduce same changes in the software and separate poets from singers, but this may cause new problems e.g. we should add a new field "Lyrics written by".
I don't think it is needed, because we deal mostly with songs.
Something else: I have a problem - our forum looks very strange for me and it's not possible to add a comment. Probably also the private chat stopped working, because nobody answers me and when I open a new tab the messages that I sent are not visible, so probably they weren't sent.
Lobolyrix
Thu, 02/02/2017 - 18:12
Hello Andrzej, a new field "Lyrics written by" - to me, it seems a very good idea!
As for your problem, I can't help you myself, because I didn't haunt in any forum up to the present. But I propose, you contact Hans (> Hansi K_Lauer), he has a lot of experience in this area :).
Candice Goddard
Tue, 02/02/2021 - 20:25
Isn't the description of a guajira incorrect?
It currently states: "Guajira: Female (white) peasant in Cuba as well as the Cuban music style Guajira" but how can that be accurate when the Guajiro people are Amerindians?






















Translations made by Lobolyrix are protected by copyrights. Commercial use only with my written permission, private use free if the author is mentioned.