Home Home
Help
Sign Up
LT → Italian, Italian (Southern Italian dialects) → Mina Celentano (23 songs translated 122 times to 20 languages)
Mina Celentano
Mina Celentano
Advanced search
Song Title, Album, Language
Mina Celentano also performedTranslations
Audio 2 - Acqua e saleItalian
Mila (2000)
Related to Mina CelentanoDescription
MinaartistMina's artist page.
Adriano CelentanoartistAdriano Celentano's artist page.
Comments
SaintMarkSaintMark    Fri, 04/11/2016 - 22:46

this is an album, not a performer.

OndagordantoOndagordanto
   Sun, 06/11/2016 - 12:45

I don't think you're right here because they act as a duo for an entire album (two albums, to be exact, if we count the new one which is about to be released in almost a week) and not only a song or two. In my opinion, their songs don't belong to only one of them (the way you've made Celentano being the main singer and Mina the featuring one) because they don't appear in any solo album of theirs, so they should be both united as a separate duo with the songs from the two albums put in here.

SaintMarkSaintMark    Sun, 06/11/2016 - 20:03

i don't agree. if you did as much database maintenance as me you'd see why i regrouped them. the database should make access to songs as simple as possible. without having to click 3 links just to figure out who is behind a name. which is not what you do when you make a folder named mina and celentano. which could be anyone or anything. adriano celentano and mina are both high profile performers. celentano is probably in the top 10 for italy. so making a folder like that is pure nonsense.

Don JuanDon Juan
   Sun, 06/11/2016 - 21:25

Sorry, but removing the content from this page is nonsense. The songs were performed by both Mina and Celentano, so they must be added to one page to prevent duplicates, their names being cited as featured artists.

OndagordantoOndagordanto
   Sun, 06/11/2016 - 21:49

Exactly. And it's not only about preventing duplicates, but making the whole searching process easier as well: imagine people needing to look up in either Mina's or Adriano's pages while knowing both of them as a [famous] duo – they would have to scroll past all the other songs (150 and 370 respectively), and in this case all the way down to the "Mina featuring" section in her page. That wouldn't make things easier.

Don JuanDon Juan
   Sun, 06/11/2016 - 21:54

Not to mention that in the 1998 album most songs are performed by the duo. It makes no sense to have a song that they both sing listed only in Mina's or Celentano's page. Leaving this page with all the lyrics and their names being added as featured artists is way better.

OndagordantoOndagordanto
   Sun, 06/11/2016 - 22:03

Absolutely. Now I'm going to bring the other songs back here while correcting their lyrics.

CoopysnoopyCoopysnoopy    Thu, 01/12/2016 - 11:27

You wrote: "Celentano is probably in the top 10 for italy." May I state more precisely: Celentano is number 1 in Italy; in nearly 60 years he sold more discs than the other Italians all together!

ScieraSciera    Sun, 06/11/2016 - 21:20

Duos which have released at least one album or EP together should get artist pages as the duo.
So I think the entry can stay as it is?

Under which name will the new album be released?

Don JuanDon Juan
   Sun, 06/11/2016 - 21:22

Mina and Celentano released two albums. Mina Celentano in 1998 and Le migliori in 2016. The page here is right for the two because it's a joint project.

SaintMarkSaintMark    Sun, 06/11/2016 - 22:52

but could you please at least put a picture of both singers instead of two rubber ducks ?

Don JuanDon Juan
   Mon, 07/11/2016 - 18:41

Well, I had put the ducks because it was the cover to their original 1998 album. But if you want to add a picture of the two, it's fine as well.

Don JuanDon Juan
   Sat, 18/11/2017 - 19:29

According to their latest single, 'Eva', their name should be sppeled as 'MinaCelentano', so I renamed this entry accordingly.

↑↓